RSS
Showing posts with label apple. Show all posts
Showing posts with label apple. Show all posts

Episode 12: Google Tries To Take a Bite Out Of Apple

The Law Filed Under: Labels: , ,
080309.0210

Recently, Google released their new product Google Voice to its first batch of users on an invite list. Let me say at the onset that Google Voice is a VERY amazing application. It is primarily a modern day switchboard, allowing you to use one Google Voice phone number to redirect a call to up to six phones. This is very useful for business people as it allows one to give out a phone number that could connect to one’s cell or home phone number without giving people your personal number (for example, my GV number is now the number on my business card). Other great features include “Speech-to-Text” voicemail, so a message left on your GV number can be stored in the GV inbox (much like Gmail), delivered via text message, and/or delivered to your email account. It also allows one to send and receive free text messages from the GV number. Google Voice also has incredible international rates. I have a buddy I call in Canada a lot for example, where our long conversations run me $32 - $45 per call on my AT&T wireless plan. With Google Voice, that same call costs .45 to .60 cents! It is important to note that Google Voice is NOT a Voice over IP (VoIP) service. To make calls from GV, I have to dial a number into GV, either by calling my GV number or calling from my computer which in turn redirects my call or dials my phone and redirecting the call respectively. Thus, Google Voice requires an existing phone service to work.

When I created my Google Voice account, there was a message informing me that Google Voice would soon be available for the iPhone. As any enthusiast would, I checked the app store constantly for the app, and eventually saw the app GV Mobile, developed by Sean Kovacs. The app was $2.99 for the premium version (which mirrored all of Google Voice’s functionality) and a free version which allowed only the placement of phone calls. I opted for the free version awaiting a first-party app that would give me full Google Voice capacity for free. A GV app is pretty necessary because Google Voice has a serious caveat – it is incredibly cumbersome to use on a cell phone. As aforementioned, to place a call with GV on a cell you have to call your Google Voice number and then dial the number you want to call. What the apps allowed was full integration with the IPhone’s phone API, so I could simply use my contact list to place phone calls; the rest of the work was done behind the scenes. It worked great; making calls from GV was just like using my iPhone. I decided to upgrade to the full version to have access to the GV voicemail which worked just like the amazing Visual Voicemail. When I deleted the GV Mobile app to upgrade to the paid version, I couldn’t find it in the iTunes store. I thought I made a mistake and decided to Google the situation to see if others had the same problem. It turned out Apple pulled the app and all other Google Voice related apps from the App Store, as well as banned the first-party Google Voice app. Naturally, the developer of GV Mobile as peeved as he wrote in his blog, his app was initially accepted into the app store. He stated that Apple responded to the revocation of GV Mobile by stating it duplicated features the iPhone already comes with.

Now the blame game starts. Apple says AT&T pressured them to remove the app. AT&T says it has no involvement in Apple’s App Store practices. This is not my very strong Apple hatred speaking here, but it makes absolutely no sense for AT&T to object to Google Voice. Let’s consider the following:

1) When the iPhone came to AT&T (it was initially offered exclusively to Verizon) AT&T basically bent over backwards for Apple, giving them pretty much free reign to make the phone without too many restrictions. It stands to reason that Apple has AT&T by the cojones because they have gotten everything they asked from them, and AT&T has too much to lose by losing their cash cow.
2) Google Voice is NOT a VoIP service! In order to use GV, the user still uses their AT&T minutes. This point is still moot because a user has to buy a 2 year contract which AT&T unless they want to pay $600 for the phone. This is not an attractive option for the majority of consumers. The only problem is with text messaging which GV will do for free. But again, why would AT&T complain? More likely than not, a user would get 2 year contract and never presumably never use the AT&T text messages. But they still get their money. Personally, I’d prefer to text with my AT&T plan, and use GV text for business, but that’s just me.

3) If AT&T has a problem with Google Voice, then why didn’t it pressure Apple to remove Skype from the app store? Skype offers calls, free text messaging, voicemail, and full integration with the iPhone contact list API. Most importantly, IT MAKES CALLS! A Skype iPhone app would really be the biggest threat to AT&T because you can completely circumvent using AT&T by putting Skype on an iPod Touch and using the Apple headset/mic. There are still other apps like IM Free and TruPhone that would allow one to circumvent AT&T’s service and iPhone all together.

Now the only flag against Google Voice for AT&T is the international calling rates, which as you saw in my example crush AT&T’s service. AT&T still gets my airtime so while I’m not paying their exorbitant international rates, they are still getting my money. However, I’m willing to wager that only a very small minority of users make a lot of international calls, at least enough to put a dent in their bottom line. Resourceful people probably already use Skype anyway, so AT&T wasn’t getting their business anyway.

It seems to me that the real culprit in this case it Apple. Apple does whatever it can to maintain an Apple only platform. That’s the main issue here. Apple in its attempt to secure its “hip” image, stifles any kind of competition. They call it quality control, I call it repressive. This case clearly illustrates my beef with Apple – they limit my choices as a consumer because they want to draw me to their product. By restricting or stifling competition, Apple funnels consumers in a one way door. I believe the way to attract consumers is not by limiting my choice, but my making your option so appealing, I choose to use your service. And If l like one part of your service but not another, I should be able to customize my experience to my liking. Not with Apple, you are stuck with whatever option they give you and usually don’t have many other ways around it.

The FCC is now getting into the mix. Techcrunch has the story here. They are looking to see if Apple’s banning of Google Voice violates any competition laws. If Google wins, this will be a serious turn of events for Apple, as the floodgates of developers denied for “duplicate functions” will surface (for the record, when the App Store debuted, I said “what is Apple if 3rd party developers could freely develop apps for the App Store? Give up? Windows!”). It was only a matter of time before Apple could keep the lid on the development community.

It’s really too bad Apple has the best consumer Smartphone on the market (I still think Blackberries are better for enterprise usage). If there was a phone that could legitimately compete with the iPhone, I’d drop that sucka like it was hot, well after my new 2 year contract expires =/

edit post

Episode 6: Ease vs. Function

The Law Filed Under: Labels: , ,
042809.1443

I’m a windows guy. I like to have options in my computing platform because I want to customize my computer experience exactly how I like it to maximize productivity. There is no question the Windows platform is compatible with the widest array of hardware and software, allowing me to configure my user experience to match specific needs. One would assume, if you have a platform that offers so many choices, there is no need for any other. However, some users require fewer options, while others require even more options. I believe that the fewer options a user has when interacting with their technology, the easier it is to use. Conversely, the more options a user has, the more difficult that technology is to use. Furthermore, technology cannot both be easy to use and have many options (technology that is difficult to use with few options is just poorly designed). Thus there is, an inverse relationship between ease of use and functionality, and this relationship is irreconcilable.

Let us compare Mac, Windows, and Linux. Mac is undeniably the easiest of the three to use. It comes installed with pretty much any program you need to get going (strangely enough no games, save chess, and no drawing programs like MS Paint). The GUI is universal, so once a user learns an app, say iTunes, the skills are directly transferable to iPhoto, Safari, Mail, and other apple programs. Apple however, is a closed platform, meaning that it lacks robust 3rd part support and most every aspect to the operating system one way or another is approved by Apple. This creates a very solid and stable system, but it is very difficult to stray too far from the Apple approved path. Therefore, Mac’s ease of use means that it is less functional

Windows is by far the most compatible platform. Just about every single application and hardware works on windows. This means that Windows users can configure their system exactly how they need to run. As a system builder, I have built computers that are solely designed to play games. Of course it can do everything else any other computer can do, but I chose specific parts to maximize processing efficiency, graphics, and sound encode/decoding. I also designed the computer in my project studio that is built to endure high level of processing for extended period of time. The drawback is the lack of standards creates the potential of system mishaps and blue screens. Windows has been trying and failing to create the universal GUI Macs have, but their lack of innovation in this department makes it difficult to create a unifying trend among apps. Thus, if you have 10 programs on windows, you will have to learn 10 different interfaces. Thus, Windows is the middle of the road. It is an open platform, which makes it the most functional operating system, but the lack of a unifying interface makes it more difficult to use than Mac.

Finally, Linux is the most configurable system. Every aspect of the computing experience can be modified exactly to your liking, even down to the placement of your minimize, restore, and close buttons. Though Linux lacks the robust hardware support of Windows, it does have a bevy of free software to customize the user experience to customize their user experience to their liking. This makes Linux a somewhat closed system because it if fully integrated into the open-source community. Also, Linux is compatible with almost all the same internal hardware as Windows allowing similar configurations for personal, enterprise, or server use. However, Linux isn’t what I’d call out-of-the-box usable, though recent versions of the most popular distribution Ubuntu is getting increasingly better with this. For example, in order to play a DVD movie, you have to grab CSS decryption software and codecs from the repository. Some applications require that you go and manually find its dependencies and compile the package to install it. Despite the excellent GUI in Ubuntu, a user needs to be able to use the terminal to get the most out of it. Between a completely configurable interface and a wide variety of software (which is 99% free) Linux is the most functional system. But it is also the most difficult to use.

We can’t have our cake and eat it too. A platform can either let the user define their experience, or create the user experience for the user to enjoy. Though the relationship is in my opionion irreconcilable, creating a unifying experience that helps to mask a platform's short commings is essential for an enjoyable user experience.

Is one model better than the other? That is debatable, but what is empirical is Apple’s stock has increased (albeit mainly from iPhone sales) while Microsoft has lost money for the first time in 23 years. Linux is increasingly becoming more popular for netbooks, phones, and is now making a presence on laptops from Dell and HP. What this indicates is middle of the road is not good enough anymore, and Microsoft is in trouble. Somehow, Microsoft has to create an interface that creates a unifying experience. Mac does this with its GUI. iTunes, iPhoto, the iPhone all look the same. They share the same name. In Linux, the unifying factor is its vibrant and passionate open-source community. Microsoft lacks this. What they do (and it continually disappoints me) is emulate rather than innovate. They see Mac using a universal GUI, so they poorly implemented it with the ribbon interface. Windows Media Player is a cheap iTunes imitation. Microsoft really has to go to the drawing board and create mind-blowing new technologies, or they will find themselves in an unrecoverable flat spin.

edit post

Episode 1: Safari 4 Beta… Hot or Not?

The Law Filed Under: Labels: , ,
032809.2125

Hello everyone! I go by the pen name TheLaw and I’d like to welcome you to my new blog L Tech Report! It is a spin-off of my political blog The L Comment. A quick bio, I am a musician and composer, and have been so for 18 years. I have a bachelors in music education, a masters in communication (TV/Radio/Film) and I have been a life long tech junkie. Yes… I do have spare motherboards in my closet for no good reason! This blog was made to share my passion for technology and innovation with the blogosphere, so please come often, leave comments, subscribe to the RSS feed, twitter me and all that good stuff!

Moving on to Episode 1, I wanted to talk about the Safari 4 beta, and Opera 10 alpha web browsers. I downloaded it and gave it a whirl a few days after it came out. I will say at the onset that I very much dislike most Apple products, but I also pride my self on my rationality, so I will always give the least biased account I can. That said, I didn’t like it very much. As of now, I very much prefer Safari 3.

One of the key issues is the placement of the tabs. I’m not sure if this is a failed Microsoft adaptation of the “ribbon” interface, or sloppy port to the Windows OS, but the tabs appear at the top of the window on the same plane as the minimize, restore, and close buttons appear. This is surprisingly horribly GUI design on Apple’s part because I believe most users block that section from their minds when browsing, much like we tend the focus reading at the center of a web page around advertisements.

The rest of the issues are tit-for tat issues that may not be a huge deal for some. I think the color scheme for safari was better in v.3 as a brushed steel silver. The interface is shinier now, and sort of resembles windows XP. Again, I haven’t tried this out on a Mac yet, so this could be a windows convention. I liked the way bookmarks appear on the personal bar in v.3 better as well. The font is now bigger, which is easier to read, but offers less viewing space, particularly noticeable on laptops.

Some really cool features include the innovative book marking system. It has a GUI facelift from version 3, adding a very awesome coverflow-like browsing system; book marked web pages can be view like albums in iTunes. It also starts up and loads pages way faster than v.3. The other sexy feature is the Top Sites window. In this view recently viewed websites are pinned on the screen for easy choosing when you create a new tab. The slick interface resembles the album view in iTunes, further accenting Apple’s commitment to a standardized Aqua interface.

Is it hot or not? It is a bit too early to tell, but it is definitely on the right track. It is faster, bolder and has nice new features, but I’d be remiss if I didn’t mention that a lot of these “new” features have already existed in my FAVORITE web browser, Opera. In the next episode, we’ll dive into Opera 10 alpha and do a little compare and contrast!

edit post